6

It says that the sub was saved for TheBuddha, if you don't know. In other words, someone set it up and held onto it for me, and I was invited here - by a number of people, but only one made the sub.

At times, I feel kinda like a spammer - even though I'm pretty sure my content is appreciated and I know some of you click through. (It tells me the referrer - it's right in the header you send to my server.)

You're a bit cliquish and I try to meander out of the guitar sub so that I can interact with the rest of you - but I don't really have time and seldom comment unless I also have time to respond to any replies to my comment. (I consider hit and run forum posting to be pretty much on par with a war crime!)

When I first showed up, I got some (legitimate) questions about why I was here - and that appears to be the end of it. Everyone kinda shrugged and went back to what they were doing and nobody has complained. Which is pretty cool, actually but I've always wondered if I'd have to explain it again.

Currently, I can point to the 'saved for TheBuddha' bit and say, "I was asked to share my content here on Phuks."

But, I still get that icky spammer feeling. I dislike spam as much as anyone else.

My question is, have we moved past that or do I seem like a spammer? I don't actually have any ulterior motives that aren't disclosed.

My ulterior motive is to interest you in spending ungodly hours learning to play a guitar, realize that the greatest factory-issued electric guitar is a Les Paul after years of study, and start a collection of them! For this, Gibson pays me zero dollars. However, it's a start that might get you interested in classical guitar and my absolute ulterior motivation lies there. I'm a shill for the Classical Guitar Cabal. They don't pay me and it's a labor of love/addiction!

I guess my question is, do I appear to be a spammer? I'm really just passionate about music and feel that I should have started this project a long time ago. It's such wonderful passion that I'd like everyone to understand it and decide if they want to take part in it.

But...

I do pretty much just submit links to my site, unless I have free time and gumption.

I welcome your feedback, 'cause I've been pondering this for quite a while now.

It says that the sub was saved for TheBuddha, if you don't know. In other words, someone set it up and held onto it for me, and I was invited here - by a number of people, but only one made the sub. At times, I feel kinda like a spammer - even though I'm pretty sure my content is appreciated and I know some of you click through. (It tells me the referrer - it's right in the header you send to my server.) You're a bit cliquish and I try to meander out of the guitar sub so that I can interact with the rest of you - but I don't really have time and seldom comment unless I *also* have time to respond to any replies to my comment. (I consider hit and run forum posting to be pretty much on par with a war crime!) When I first showed up, I got some (legitimate) questions about why I was here - and that appears to be the end of it. Everyone kinda shrugged and went back to what they were doing and nobody has complained. Which is pretty cool, actually but I've always wondered if I'd have to explain it again. Currently, I can point to the 'saved for TheBuddha' bit and say, "I was asked to share my content here on Phuks." But, I still get that icky spammer feeling. I dislike spam as much as anyone else. My question is, have we moved past that or do I seem like a spammer? I don't actually have any ulterior motives that aren't disclosed. My ulterior motive is to interest you in spending ungodly hours learning to play a guitar, realize that the greatest factory-issued electric guitar is a Les Paul after years of study, and start a collection of them! For this, Gibson pays me zero dollars. However, it's a start that might get you interested in classical guitar and my absolute ulterior motivation lies there. I'm a shill for the Classical Guitar Cabal. They don't pay me and it's a labor of love/addiction! I guess my question is, do I appear to be a spammer? I'm really just passionate about music and feel that I should have started this project a long time ago. It's such wonderful passion that I'd like everyone to understand it and decide if they want to take part in it. But... I do pretty much just submit links to my site, unless I have free time and gumption. I welcome your feedback, 'cause I've been pondering this for quite a while now.

15 comments

[–] TheBuddha [OP] 1 points (+1|-0)

Oh, here:

I'm here pretty much exclusively for guitar and because not all people post on all three sites. It may not be large, but there is some commentary that I get here and I don't get that commentary on the other sites. This enables them, and myself, to have a discussion - specifically about the guitar.

There is only a very small guitar community here, but I want one to be available - should people choose to participate.

My activity here is very focused and I do meander out and leave comments (or make the rare submission) but those are infrequent. My feelings won't even be a little hurt if I were asked to stop posting. At the end of the day, I just try to make it available and there are people who may not wish to comment on Voat or Poal.

Yes, I do have ads. As you surmised, they are not a source of significant income. I think Google prohibits discussing exact figures for income or click-through rates, but they're both really low. Like 60%+ actually block ads and I don't actually mind that they do.

[–] Hitchens 1 points (+1|-0) Edited

I would never want you to stop posting, I’m just voicing why I don’t participate. You’re not the only user here I ignore. Fuck, I’m sure I’m an annoying left wing asshole to at least few users here.

Do you.

One other note, I was actually thinking this when I was voat. You really need your own sub, not the generic guitar sub. Like Buddha’s place or something. The base here is very small, those who participated in guitar threads here would find it. That way you can post about your blueberries and all the other riches you have at your disposal. The large guitar threads at voat needed a better sub IMO because it doesn’t seem to include all music its users make. Sub name: the jam night or your music but just v/guitar or /s/guitar is to general.

Just thoughts.

[–] TheBuddha [OP] 1 points (+1|-0)

I'll keep it in mind. I have had some great experiences and I do like to share 'em with people. I've even met a few goats, but I'm not really sure I have enough content to keep a more generic sub going. Hmm...

I'm actually cutting back on some of my Voat posting, largely due to time and (this is gonna make me sound really pompous perhaps) largely because you can't reason someone out of a position they didn't reason themselves into. Which is a polite way of saying that it's pretty futile to explain political science to someone who believes the apex of debate is calling the other person a Jew and saying that they know now you eat babies.

I can only bang my head against a wall for so long before I get bored. It's pretty much reached the point where I don't even visit their science subs. I had pretty high hopes for Voat, and I legitimately like many of the users, and have an undying love for free speech. I'd go on, but I suspect I'd be preaching to the choir.

And, as I've been pretty busy lately, that's meant cutting back.

Which makes me think of something...

I am not sure how much time I can devote to it, but would there be enough activity for a "Weekly Musician Hang-out" (or similar) on Phuks? I probably can't commit to starting it weekly, personally - but I'd try to help provide content when time did allow. I do know that it's brought quite a few people together, and been a net-positive, on Voat - but this is definitely not Voat.

Until Voat dies, I'm pretty obligated to continue the thread there. I don't even get to attend all of those threads anymore.

Hmm...

[–] Hitchens 1 points (+1|-0)

can't reason someone out of a position they didn't reason themselves into

One of my favorite quotes and also one of the main reasons I left voat.

I'd go on, but I suspect I'd be preaching to the choir.

You are but who doesn’t love a good reinforcement of ones own feelings.

A hang out thread or sub had its peak about a year and half ago on voat and it’s hard with voats shortcomings to keep hang out subs motivated. I believe a hang out sub or thread needs more then one passionate mod. You need a team or two or three. You could try that here on phuks but can’t think of a user here with that kind of dedication you have for music or sharing music.

Every passionate mod needs a helper. Just like most big thinkers have assistants and people to help pick up all the creative pieces.

Every picture needs a frame and every frame needs a picture, sometimes it’s just hard to find the right one to match.