10

I'm almost done rewatching the star trek Voyager series and I figure they burn/crash/shoot down atleast a dozen shuttle craft per season. this is usually just before the crew is miraculously beamed out at the last moment before the shuttle explodes, but that is just usual Star Trek protocol.

Let's say a third of those shuttles are actually damaged beyond repair, that makes 4 lost per season * 7 = 28 shuttles over the entire series...

They also rebuild the Deltaflyer after that gets destroyed in S7.

So halfway S5 Tom Paris wants to buy an alien shuttle at a scrapyard (with the rate they burn trough shuttle's you'd think it's a good deal but then commander Chakotgay says: "we have a full compliment of shuttles and the deltaflyer, we dont need another craft..."

The same Chakotgay who keeps mentioning to people they need to conserve energy and food..... You would think a ship that runs trough so many shuttles could use a spare. I mean Enterprise and DS9 could get new shuttles from supply lines or space stations no worries, just send a few new ones out from earth or wherever they built these insane amount of shuttlecraft. But out in the delta Quadrant....

Did we miss an entire deck with a Shuttle manufacturing line and a "chief engineer of shuttles" during the entire series or are they just bulshitting us?

I'm almost done rewatching the star trek Voyager series and I figure they burn/crash/shoot down atleast a dozen shuttle craft per season. this is usually just before the crew is miraculously beamed out at the last moment before the shuttle explodes, but that is just [usual Star Trek protocol.](http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-Eg_4kg813VM/ULJIyO6TLyI/AAAAAAAADdc/ed_QXKoMMXc/s1600/captain-picard-waving.gif) Let's say a third of those shuttles are actually damaged beyond repair, that makes 4 lost per season * 7 = 28 shuttles over the entire series... They also rebuild the Deltaflyer after that gets destroyed in S7. So halfway S5 Tom Paris wants to buy an alien shuttle at a scrapyard (with the rate they burn trough shuttle's you'd think it's a good deal but then commander Chakotgay says: ["we have a full compliment of shuttles and the deltaflyer, we dont need another craft..."](http://media.giphy.com/media/d02CaXYF5H5ra/giphy.gif) The same Chakotgay who keeps mentioning to people they need to conserve energy and food..... You would think a ship that runs trough so many shuttles could use a spare. I mean Enterprise and DS9 could get new shuttles from supply lines or space stations no worries, just send a few new ones out from earth or wherever they built these insane amount of shuttlecraft. But out in the delta Quadrant.... Did we miss an entire deck with a Shuttle manufacturing line and a ["chief engineer of shuttles"](http://blog.wilcoxfamily.net/photos/doug.jpg) during the entire series or are they just bulshitting us?

4 comments

[–] pembo210 4 points (+4|-0)

I loved Voyager, but this kinda bothered me too in the back of my mind. Why did they use so much energy replicating new equipment and exterior plating..

I like the episode where 7-of-9 downloaded and processed all the logs at night and came up with the idea that Janeway purposefully got them stuck in the Delta quadrant so starfleet could have a base there. This makes even more sense if voyager had a super efficient shuttle replicators.

[–] TheRedArmy 2 points (+2|-0)

One of my favorite episodes, "The Voyager Conspiracy". Piecing together a cohesive narrative like that in solving any kind of puzzle, mystery, or things along those lines are always really interesting to me. That's probably why I like Game Theory and Film Theory on Youtube a fair bit (although when you know the source material really well, you can poke flaws in the shit all the time, but whatever).

She also came up with a theory about a Maquis plot that involved them purposefully getting stuck in the quadrant, but that one makes no sense - at least the Starfleet one kind of makes sense.

[–] TheRedArmy 3 points (+3|-0)

It's the same with the thing where the ship itself doesn't show any damage from week to week. It makes sense for DS9 and the Enterprise - they're in Federation space, they make stop-offs at starbases all the time, so they get some maintenance, rotate crews, repair damage, etc. Remember an entire episode (TNG: Starship Mine) is based around them being docked at a Starbase for a Baryon sweep maintenance, so they took it seriously then. But in reality, the USS Voyager would have broken down in season 2 at the latest, because those ships are clearly designed for regular maintenance that they just don't have access to.

It's one of these suspensions of disbelief you have to go with for the show to even work.

[–] phoxy 2 points (+2|-0)

Replicators, man! They just replicate a new one, easy peasy.