It's very very bad science.
To be fair, it is high school. That kid might only be 15. These projects aren't the pinnacle of scientific merit.
>It's very very bad science.
To be fair, it is high school. That kid might only be 15. These projects aren't the pinnacle of scientific merit.
I'd love to see a fair scientific look at the question posed by the student. I don't think anyone should be punished for asking, or researching, even if it does hurt feelings.
But this kid wasn't doing that.
You can not draw those conclusions from that data, not that that's enough data points to draw any conclusions from.
There seems to be no controls for things like affluence and culture.
It's very very bad science.
Almost like he was trying to fit the facts to a chosen narrative and cause a scene to upset people and get attention. But that's just speculation.
Still, he should not be silenced, he should be publicly corrected and encouraged to redo the study with more rigorous methods.